A Choral Director posted this on the Facebook page of a major choral music organization.
Here are her accompanying comments in blue.
This is my philosophy. What do you think? This is from an article on cultivating children's choirs from the most recent issue of the ACDA magazine.
It was posted 12 hours ago. In that time, there have been over 300 likes/loves, and over 100 shares. Almost all of the people who have responded are in total agreement with the sentiment expressed in it. They've written comments like "Preach", "Amen", "I'm posting it in my choir room", and more.
I died inside just a little bit when I read all of this. As a middle school educator with over 24 years of experience teaching in a diverse public school setting, all I thought about was how many singers are lost each year due to this sort of philosophy.
It feels so "old school". It reminds me of corporal punishment. It's like 1953. It brings back memories of the way we used to train dogs not to poop inside the house...
...by rubbing their noses in it.
It is this sort of antiquated attitude and approach that causes so many middle school choral programs around the USA to be so small.
The students run from it because it is feels like drudgery taught with a scowl.
Have we forgotten that "A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down?!"
I find it so hard to believe this was printed in such a major choral director's magazine (giving it credibility), and I am amazed that so many people have piled on in agreement.
If you want to fail as a middle school choral music teacher, you should definitely follow the advice ("It's not about having fun") in the above posting, and let it be your guiding light.
People with this philosophy should not teach middle school. I've seen so many of my colleagues come and go over the years because they approach the classroom in this manner. They need to be teaching at college or teaching only the most elite high schoolers...and even then, I think fun is near the top of all priorities.
I was a volunteer in a major singing organization in my area for several years, and I absolutely adored singing with the group. The director was incredibly competent and musical. She was able to get a super, dynamic sound out of volunteers. The group was one of the largest of its kind in the country. There was never a single night when I didn't get goose bumps as we created art together under her leadership. I looked forward to every 2 1/2 hour rehearsal on Thursday nights. Each night, there was laughter amongst us and between us as we worked to perfect the music.
A new choir director came in, and it was no longer fun. The approach was very disciplined, but there was no laughter and no time to just be a human. The quality of the singing the group produced was no better than the previous director. In my view the sound was sterile and unemotional, and the process of learning was much less enjoyable. So, I left the group...and I'm old. We all need fun and laughter. The group has continued to shrink and age along with it's audiences.
Fun and singing go hand and hand.
Here is what I know based on my experience: Our middle school beginners must have fun. Is it going to happen every minute of every day of every rehearsal? No...but we have got to stay connected to what helps open up their hearts and allows them to enjoy the process of learning to take the signs and symbols off the page and make art from it.
It's also about structure and boundaries in a huge way, but without fun and laughter occasionally, you are not going to attract students to your program. Kids talk. If your class is a bore, no matter how good they sound or how many superiors you get at adjudications or how many Allstate Chorus members you have each year, your program is going to stay small.
I teach 340 volunteer middle school students each and every day in classes with as many students as 84 from "bell to bell". It's nonstop. They work. I give them structure from the very first day, and I tolerate very little. I do everything I can do make the process of learning to read music as enjoyable as possible...again, from the very first day. Middle school children need to be understood, and sometimes we need to allow them to fail. I've covered this stuff on my YouTube Channel and in my blog for years now, so if you want to read more about my approach to the classroom, just type in "classroom management", and you can watch and read ad nauseum!
I couldn't do my job if I were easy on them...if I didn't have processes in place...and if I scowled all day and made it feel like work. There is a balance...and the "fun" part is what tilts it in your favor.
Before I created S-Cubed Middle School Sight Singing Program for Beginners, I created a product called "What do you MEAN I can't Smile Before Christmas?!?" because I so strongly believe that middle school students need structure and boundaries, but they also need FUN. They need to see the human side of us.
We have to help this age group WANT to work with us.
We have to find a way to make work not feel like work whenever we can so we can keep these young singers singing!
And life is way too short not to have fun.
I hope the end of your school year is going great!
Check out my blog!