I Didn’t Get Goosebumps in 2013 Either. But I Knew It Would Help Teachers

I Didn’t Get Goosebumps in 2013 Either. But I Knew It Would Help Teachers.

Reflections on my conversation with Chris Munce of Choralosophy, artificial intelligence, and why my mission hasn’t changed.

Recently, I had the opportunity to sit down with Chris Munce for another conversation on his Choralosophy podcast.

Here is the link to our talk.

Here is a clip to get a feel for the conversation. 1 minute.

Chris and I have known each other for years, and one of the things I appreciate about him is his willingness to have conversations that aren’t always comfortable.

In some of his promotion for our conversation, Chris acknowledged something that I think deserves attention. He’s using AI himself, while also navigating a very fine line between embracing the technology, being transparent about using it, and recognizing that many people in the music education community have strong feelings against it.

I understand that fine line.

I’ve been walking it myself.

But something Chris highlighted from our conversation really stuck with me.

I admitted that creating my new S-Cubed AI Coach didn’t give me the “feels.”

No goosebumps. No overwhelming artistic experience. No magical moment when I felt transported by what I was creating.

And here’s the thing.

I didn’t get those feelings in 2013 when I was uploading YouTube videos and lessons to TPT for hours and hours on end , either.

Let’s Go Back to 2013

When I began creating the S-Cubed Sight Singing Program for Beginners, I spent countless hours recording videos, developing lessons, organizing materials, uploading content to YouTube, and eventually making everything available through Teachers Pay Teachers.

It was an enormous amount of work.

Hundreds of videos. Lesson after lesson. Endless hours of preparation, editing, uploading, and figuring out technology that was still relatively new to many teachers.

Did I get goosebumps uploading those videos?

Absolutely not.

Did I experience some profound artistic revelation while organizing lesson files and preparing materials for Teachers Pay Teachers?

Nope.

I was working.

But I knew something important.

I knew that what I was creating could help teachers.

I knew that there were middle school choral directors who were struggling to teach sight singing, who needed a sequence they could trust, and who wanted their students to experience success.

I knew what had worked in my classroom, and I wanted to make it available to others.

That was my motivation.

Not the technology.

Not the platform.

Not the excitement of uploading videos.

The teachers. And ultimately, their students.

Creating Art and Creating Tools Are Two Different Things

This is where I think some of our conversations about artificial intelligence in music education get tangled up.

When we’re standing in front of a choir and something extraordinary happens musically, that’s art.

When singers connect with a piece of music, listen deeply to one another, shape a phrase together, and create something beautiful that didn’t exist a moment earlier, that’s art.

I’ve experienced those moments throughout my career.

Those moments absolutely gave me goosebumps.

Some of the most profound experiences of my life have happened through choral music.

But creating a curriculum to help teachers develop those experiences?

That’s a different kind of work.

And creating an AI-powered coaching tool to help teachers become more confident and effective in their classrooms?

That’s work, too.

I don’t need to feel artistic inspiration while building a tool for that tool to have value.

I need to know that it works.

I need to know that it helps.

And I need to know that it serves the people I created it for.

Same Mission. Different Technology.

In 2013, I used the technology available to me to share what I had learned from years of teaching middle school chorus.

YouTube helped me demonstrate lessons.

Teachers Pay Teachers helped me distribute the curriculum.

My blog helped me communicate with teachers and share their experiences.

None of those technologies created the musical experiences that happened in classrooms.

Teachers did that.

Students did that.

The technology simply helped make those experiences possible.

Now it’s 2026.

And I have another tool.

Artificial intelligence.

I’ve spent countless hours building my S-Cubed AI Coach, drawing from the same teaching experience, the same curriculum, and the same commitment to helping middle school choral directors.

This time, instead of simply watching a video or reading a lesson plan, teachers can ask questions.

They can get help thinking through classroom management challenges.

They can ask about pacing, differentiation, reluctant singers, changing male voices, and the hundreds of situations that arise when you’re teaching real children in a real classroom.

Is the AI Coach making art?

No.

It’s helping teachers do the work that makes art possible.

And that’s a distinction I think matters enormously.

I Understand the Discomfort

I know that many music educators are deeply concerned about artificial intelligence.

Some worry about creativity. Others worry about authenticity, intellectual property, the future of artistic professions, and the possibility that human musicianship will somehow become less valuable.

Those are legitimate concerns.

And I don’t believe we should dismiss them.

But I also don’t believe that using AI to support teachers means we’re abandoning our commitment to human artistry.

I don’t see those things as mutually exclusive.

A teacher who uses technology to better understand how to teach changing male voices isn’t replacing the human experience of singing.

A teacher who gets help managing a difficult classroom isn’t replacing the relationship between teacher and student.

A teacher who uses an AI Coach to think through tomorrow’s lesson isn’t asking a machine to create the magic that happens when young people make music together.

They’re preparing to do their jobs more effectively.

And that matters.

What Chris Helped Me Recognize

One of the things I appreciate about Chris Munce is that he’s willing to acknowledge the complicated reality of this moment.

We can use emerging technology, recognize its usefulness, and still ask difficult questions about its place in our profession.

We can be transparent about what we’re doing without pretending that everyone is going to agree with us.

And we can distinguish between the deeply human experience of creating art and the practical work required to support that experience.

When Chris pointed out that I hadn’t gotten the “feels” while creating my AI Coach, it helped me recognize something I hadn’t fully articulated.

I wasn’t trying to create an artistic experience for myself.

I was trying to create something useful for somebody else.

Just like I was in 2013.

Thirteen Years Later

Since I first launched S-Cubed, the program has reached thousands of teachers and more than 100,000 students.

I’ve heard from teachers who found their confidence.

I’ve heard from teachers whose students began reading music when they previously couldn’t.

I’ve heard from educators who finally felt they had a practical, manageable way to teach sight singing.

Those stories mean more to me than any excitement I might have felt uploading a video in 2013.

And now, with my AI Coach, I hope to help another generation of teachers find that same confidence.

I don’t know exactly where artificial intelligence will take our profession.

Nobody does.

But I know why I’m participating in this moment.

It’s the same reason I began creating S-Cubed thirteen years ago.

To share what I’ve learned.

To support teachers.

To help students succeed.

And to make it a little easier for more young people to experience the extraordinary power of singing together.

The technology has changed.

The work has changed.

The mission hasn’t.

And when a teacher tells me that something I created helped their students experience the joy of making music?

That’s when I get the goosebumps.


I’m grateful to Chris Munce and Choralosophy for making room for thoughtful conversations about music education, technology, and the future of our profession.





When your middle school choir becomes a dumping ground- What do you do?

When Your Middle School Choir Becomes the Dumping Ground: What Do You Do?

You became a music teacher to teach music. But what happens when your choir classroom becomes the place where students are sent simply because they need somewhere to go?

If you've taught middle school choir long enough, you probably know exactly what I'm talking about.

You have students who genuinely love singing. They want to learn. They want to perform. They signed up because music means something to them.

And then you have students who never wanted to be there in the first place.

Some were placed in choir because their first elective choice was full. Others were assigned to your class because there wasn't anywhere else to put them. Some may have been told that choir would be an easy A.

Suddenly, you're not just teaching music.

You're trying to convince an entire group of students that your subject deserves their attention.

And sometimes, the students who don't want to be there are the loudest voices in the room.

Here's the Classroom Scenario

Imagine this:

You're standing in front of your seventh-grade choir.

Thirty students are ready to rehearse. Several are excited about an upcoming performance.

But eight students have absolutely no interest in singing.

They talk while you're teaching. They distract their classmates. They refuse to participate. A few openly announce that they hate choir.

You've tried encouragement. You've tried building relationships. You've tried explaining why participation matters.

But nothing seems to change.

And the students who actually WANT to learn are starting to suffer.

What would YOU do?

Before you read any further, think about how you would handle this situation.

Would you change your expectations? Contact parents? Talk to administration? Find alternative ways for reluctant students to participate?

Or is there something else you've discovered that actually works?

The Problem Isn't Always the Teacher

One of the most frustrating things about this situation is that teachers sometimes feel personally responsible for every student's lack of enthusiasm.

But let's acknowledge something important.

You cannot manufacture enthusiasm simply because a student has been assigned to your classroom.

And when students are placed in an elective without choosing it, the challenges can be very real.

That doesn't mean those students are incapable of enjoying music.

In fact, some of the most rewarding teaching moments happen when a reluctant student discovers something they never knew they could do.

But getting there requires thoughtful strategies, patience, and realistic expectations.

It also requires protecting the learning environment for the students who genuinely want to be there.

Those students deserve a meaningful musical education, too.

I Asked My S-Cubed Coach This Exact Question

I've been developing an AI coaching resource specifically for middle school choir teachers.

It's built around the teaching experience, classroom challenges, and instructional philosophy behind my S-Cubed Sight Singing Program for Beginners.

And one of the things I love most about it is that teachers can bring real classroom problems to the conversation.

Not hypothetical problems from a college textbook.

REAL problems.

The kind that make you sit in your car after school and wonder how you're going to get through tomorrow's rehearsal.

So I presented my coach with this situation:

My middle school choir has become a dumping ground for students who didn't choose the class. Some refuse to sing, disrupt rehearsals, and make it difficult for the students who want to learn. How can I turn this around?

Then I recorded the coach's response.

And that's what I'm sharing in my latest YouTube video.

I want teachers to hear how an AI resource designed around the realities of middle school choir can help them think through a difficult situation.

Not by replacing their judgment.

Not by pretending there's a magic solution.

But by offering practical ideas they can consider, adapt, and implement in their own classrooms.

Watch the video: When Your Choir Becomes the Dumping Ground — My AI Coach Responds

Here is the link to the short video showing the response from my Coach.

Why I'm Sharing These Conversations

When I created S-Cubed back in 2013, my goal was to help teachers feel more successful teaching sight singing and to have fun while doing it.  I wanted teachers and students to enjoy learning the topic and also to obtain really high-level skills in the subject of sight-singing.  

But after years of working with middle school music educators, I know that sight singing is only one piece of the puzzle.

Teachers also struggle with classroom management, student motivation, scheduling, adolescent development, changing voices, and countless other challenges.

And sometimes, what a teacher needs most is simply someone to help them think through a problem.

That's what I'm working to provide with my S-Cubed AI Coach.

A resource that's available when you need it.

A place to ask questions without worrying about being judged.

And a way to explore solutions while still keeping the human teacher at the center of every decision.

Now I Want to Hear From YOU

Have you ever taught a choir that felt like the school's dumping ground?

Did you find a way to turn things around?

What worked? What didn't?

And what do you wish your administrators understood about placing students in music electives they didn't choose?

Share your experience in the comments.

Somewhere out there is a teacher dealing with this exact situation TODAY.

And your experience might be precisely what that teacher needs to hear.

If you'd like to explore how my S-Cubed AI Coach can help with challenges like this one, you can learn more here:

Explore the S-Cubed AI Coach

Because middle school choir teaching is challenging enough.

You shouldn't have to figure everything out alone.

— Dale Duncan

Creator, S-Cubed Sight Singing Program for Beginners

If you’ve built an audience around your expertise, you may be sitting on an app idea without realizing it. Studio gave me a way to turn years of teaching knowledge, resources, and philosophy into an interactive AI Coach—and creators in many different fields could do the same. If you’ve ever thought, “I wish I could put what I know into something people could use anytime,” take a look at Studio through my affiliate link here: 

https://studio.com/join/daleduncanscubedcoach


You'll be in good company if you do it!  Idina Menzel’s app-  


https://studio.com/apps/studio/idina-menzel





Special S-Cubed Mega Bundle Giveaway and S-Cubed AI Coach - ONE DAY ONLY. November 9, 2026

Music Teachers! Something BIG Is Coming November 9! 🎶

I'm Giving Away My S-Cubed Sight Singing Mega Bundle — Plus a Special Opportunity to Experience My New AI Coach!  And see my brand new Store at SCubedMusic.com where you will be able to get my biggest bundles for less by buying directly from me!  I just opened it this week!  Go take a look!

Over the years, I've had the privilege of working with thousands of music teachers who share one important goal: helping students become confident, independent musicians.

And if you've followed my work for a while, you know how passionate I am about helping middle school chorus teachers succeed.

On November 9, I'm celebrating those teachers with a special S-Cubed GIVEAWAY!

This giveaway was inspired by an upcoming presentation for the North Carolina Music Educators Association (NCMEA), where teachers will have an opportunity to learn about my S-Cubed Sight Singing Program for Beginners and my newest project, the S-Cubed AI Coach.

But here's the exciting part:

You don't have to be in North Carolina to enter!

I'm opening this giveaway to music teachers everywhere on November 9!

🎁 What Can You Win?

One lucky teacher will receive TWO special prizes!

PRIZE #1: My S-Cubed Sight Singing Program for Beginners — MEGA BUNDLE!

This is the comprehensive curriculum I've developed to help teachers build a successful sight-singing program, even when their students have little or no previous experience reading music.

S-Cubed was born out of my own experiences teaching middle school chorus. I wanted a way to make sight-singing fun, approachable, sequential, engaging, and successful for beginners.

Teachers across the country are using these resources to help their students develop musical independence and have done so since 2013.

The winner receives the Mega Bundle absolutely FREE!

PRIZE #2: Three Months of My S-Cubed AI Coach for Just $5!

I've spent years presenting workshops, writing articles, and helping teachers solve the everyday challenges of teaching middle school chorus.

Now I've brought that experience into something entirely new.

My S-Cubed AI Coach is designed to be your 24/7 middle school choral teaching partner.

Imagine having a resource you can turn to when you're wondering:

  • What do I do when one section talks while I'm teaching another?

  • How can I help reluctant singers participate?

  • How should I approach the changing male voice?

  • How can I improve classroom management without sacrificing rehearsal time?

  • How can I build a stronger, more successful choral program?

My AI Coach draws on the teaching strategies, experiences, and resources I've developed throughout my career.

And I'm continuing to make it better!

The giveaway winner will have the opportunity to experience three full months of the S-Cubed AI Coach for a total of just $5.

📅 Mark Your Calendar: November 9, 2026!

Teachers attending the North Carolina presentation will receive a special QR code at 7:00 PM on November 9 to enter.

But I'm doing something a little different.

Anyone who visits this blog on November 9 from 12:01 AM until 11:59 PM that day will also have an opportunity to enter the giveaway!

Whether you're teaching in North Carolina, Georgia, California, Texas, or anywhere else, I want you to have a chance.

At the bottom of this blog, you'll find the link to enter.  There are three ways to enter-  Leave your personal email address (some school addresses have filters that block emails).  There are two more ways to enter to increase your odds simply by answering some questions.  

🎉 And Here's Something Special for EVERYONE Who Enters!

I don't want this to be just about one winner.

On November 10, everyone who enters the giveaway will receive a special email from me.

Inside that email will be exclusive discount opportunities for:

My S-Cubed Sight Singing Mega Bundle

AND

My S-Cubed AI Coach!

These special offers will be available for a limited time, and I'll share the details directly with everyone who enters.

So even if your name isn't selected as the winner, you'll still have something to look forward to!

Make sure to check your email on 11/10/26.  

Why Am I Doing This?

Because teaching middle school chorus is an extraordinary job.

It's also a challenging one.

I remember the days when I was trying to teach one voice part while another section was talking. I remember the reluctant singers, the changing voices, the classroom management struggles, and the wonderful moments when everything finally came together.

Those experiences inspired me to create S-Cubed.

And now, years later, they've inspired me to create my AI Coach.

Technology has changed dramatically since I began teaching, but one thing hasn't changed:

Great teachers make the difference.

My goal has always been to give those teachers practical tools that make their jobs easier and help their students succeed.

This giveaway is one more way to share those tools.

Here's What You Can Do Right Now!

Save the date: November 9!

Share this post with a music teacher who might benefit from S-Cubed.

And come back on November 9 to enter!

In the meantime, if you're curious about my newest project, you can explore the S-Cubed AI Coach here:

Use this link to see the free onboarding process on my S-Cubed AI Coach on Studio.com. 

I'm excited to celebrate music teachers, introduce more people to these resources, and give one lucky teacher a wonderful surprise!

See you November 9!

Enter with the link below-   

Special S-Cubed Giveaway for North Carolina, and anyone lucky enough to find this post and enter on November 9th-  ONE DAY ONLY!  

Dale Duncan

Creator, S-Cubed Sight Singing Program for Beginners

Creator, S-Cubed AI Coach

Giveaway entry details, eligibility, winner selection, and the terms of the November 10 special offers will be provided with the official entry form. Entry is free; no purchase is necessary. The optional $5 AI Coach access is separate from the free Mega Bundle prize.